“You have stolen my dreams and my childhood with your empty words.” — Greta Thunberg, United Nations, Sept. 23, 2019.
Here’s a question someone should ask climate expert Greta Thunberg today. What if global warming is preventing the next ice age? Wouldn’t that be a good thing for children everywhere?
Turns out, a new study published in the highly respected journal Science says that might be exactly what’s happening right now.
The study, which goes by the unassuming title of “Late Holocene re-expansion of the Laurentide Ice Sheet,” asks whether “anthropogenic warming prevented the next glacial cycle” and finds that “it may have done just that.”
The researchers looked at the Laurentide Ice Sheet (LIS), which covered much of North America at the peak of the last ice age, and began retreating nearly 12,000 years ago in what is called today’s Holocene period (the Great Lakes were carved out by the retreat of this ice sheet).
What they found was that “after shrinking throughout much of the early- and mid-Holocene, the LIS began to grow again around 2,000 years ago but then began shrinking once more around 1960. The authors attribute this reversal to anthropogenic greenhouse forcing, evidence that humans caused the termination of the next glaciation,” writes Science’s Jesse Smith in the “Editor’s summary.” (Emphasis added.)
Nicolás Young, a geochemist at the Columbia Climate School and one of the study’s authors, put it in layman’s terms, telling Phys.org that: “It was just getting started, everything was normal, the next glaciation was about to happen — and yet it stopped.” (The University of Colorado Boulder called it “The failed ice age.”)
The fact that a new glacial period had begun should not be a surprise to anyone who knows anything about the history of ice ages.
The climate record shows that ice ages are a recurring phenomenon that last far longer than “interglacial” periods like the one we are in right now (80,000 years vs. 10,000 years, roughly). And global temperatures during previous interglacials were far higher than today’s “hottest year on record.” The chart below shows this in dramatic fashion.

Scientists also know that the next ice age would be catastrophic for mankind, threatening, among other things, mass starvation as cropland shrinks.
What’s more, the current interglacial is now more than 11,700 years old. Which means we are due for another ice age in the relatively near future.
In fact, back in the 1970s, some scientists were predicting the onset of the next ice age. (Time magazine ran an article on June 24, 1974, titled “Another Ice Age?” Newsweek ran a feature article on April 28, 1975, titled “The Cooling World” in which it said that “The evidence in support of these predictions has now begun to accumulate so massively that meteorologists are hard pressed to keep up with it.”)
Climate types later dismissed those ice age fears as unfounded. But, as the Phys.org article puts it:
The findings [in the Science study] are also a coda for climate scientists who in the 1970s made the controversial claim that a new ice age was imminent. ‘It actually was happening,’ Young says. ‘They couldn’t quite prove it, but now we sort of have the evidence.’
So, if these researchers are right, the carbon emissions that climate zealots want stopped appear to have halted, or at least put off, the next ice age.
Shouldn’t this be cause for celebration? And shouldn’t we be encouraging everyone to keep burning as much fossil fuel as possible for as long as possible? And shouldn’t Greta Thunberg, when she’s not too busy pimping for Hamas terrorists, apologize to future generations for her “how dare you” speech?
More likely we will start hearing about how stopping the next ice age is an even worse environmental catastrophe.
UPDATE: As we suspected, this new study is being dismissed. Here’s CNN’s headline from Oct. 29: “Humans accidentally canceled the next ice age — but it’s no reason to celebrate, scientists say“
— Written by the I&I Editorial Board









Larry Niven wrote Fallen Angels back in 2011 which hypothesizes that the Green New Deal reverses global warming and brings in a new ice age. I keep praying for more warming because it’s hard to grow wheat on a mile-deep sheet of ice.
Type “Global Temperature and CO2 levels over 600 million years” into a search engine, or search for the article “Global Warming and Climate change, causes, impacts and mitigation” written by Sivakumaran Sivaramanan and look at Figure 1. The graph shows that over geological periods of time, CO2 levels and global temperatures are near all-time lows. Our current era of recurring glacial cycles is a deviation from what is normal for Earth.
CO2 levels have been near 3000 ppm for most of the past 250 million years, but we are agonizing over an increase from 270 to 427 ppm. Plant life needs CO2 to grow and the level was getting dangerously low before humans increased it.
You said, “Climate types later dismissed those ice age fears as unfounded.”
Climate scientists know that natural cycles (the Milankovitch Cycles) were leading us to the next glacial advance, thousands of years in the future, But yes, we have altered that future by burning huge amounts of fossil fuels.
I’m sure there are some non-scientist “climate types” who don’t know that.
Burning more now is not necessary or helpful, and it causes a lot of other problems, as scientists have been saying.
Perhaps it would be prudent to leave most of the remaining fossil fuels in the ground, in case our descendants need them, thousands of years in the future, to prevent glaciation again.
It would be more prudent to ignore you.
Seriously, that’s your position?
For decades we’ve been told by folks like you that CO2 emissions would boil the planet and extinguish humanity, and that we must get to net zero immediately if we are to have any chance of survival. A new study finds that CO2 emissions may have stopped the onset of a new ice age, and your response is — so what, let’s impoverish ourselves today by keeping a cheap and abundant source of energy in the ground so we can prevent another ice age sometime in the far distant future. That’s got to be the weakest case for “net zero” I have ever heard.
Folks like me try to follow the science. I’ve known about the Milankovitch cycles and the effects of CO2 in preventing or reducing the next glacial period for many years. This new study just reinforces what we already knew.
It doesn’t mean that continuing to increase atmospheric and oceanic CO2 won’t cause a lot of problems. It will, and it has already begun to show them.
If everyone “already knew” this, they sure kept it a closely guarded secret. In any case, if CO2 emissions are peventing or putting off or mitigating an ice age, that’s a pretty big freaking deal as far as we humans are concerned. Shouldn’t scientists be weighing the benefits of that, rather than just focusing on “a lot of problems” that CO2 emissions might cause?
As another one told me, regarding gee, stop feeding the troll. It is akin to wrestling with a pig…
See the BBC article, “Carbon emissions ‘will defer Ice Age”.
Published 9 January 2012
what a massive load of codswallop
I agree. StPaulChuck has written “… a massive load of codswallop.”
Personally, I think this was a very interesting (and certainly enlightening) editorial-and remember it was based on the data and interpretations of the reputable journal, Science.
Wow! Perhaps Global Warming will cause Dem/DSA’s/and all Leftists to by stymied, halted and retreat from the chaos they’ve caused!
We are coming out of an Ice Age. Geologic time is very, very slow.
Mankind now faces its most existential challenge ever:
Contriving some way of blaming itself for the impending ice age and flagellating itself for it.
-We only have 12 years before we all become freezer-burnt!
-The polar bears are taking over the planet!
-There’s TOO MUCH ice in the polar caps!
-The typhoons that the South Pacific depends upon for its water are at historic lows!