Weeks before the midterm elections, U.S. Rep. Jamie Raskin, D-Md., introduced a congressional resolution “expressing concern about the growing problem of book banning and the proliferation of threats to freedom of expression in the United States.”
Raskin likely will chair the House Judiciary Committee in the new Congress, and many of the bill’s 75 cosponsors, all Democrats, will hold other key positions. So expect more on this issue in the months ahead.
The bill was introduced on the eve of “Banned Books Week 2026,” an annual campaign orchestrated by the American Library Association (ALA) and a group of allied organizations, the Banned Books Week Coalition. Not coincidentally, Rep. Raskin’s congressional website states that one of his books, “We the Students: Supreme Court Cases for and About America’s Students,” was “banned by the Texas State Board of Education.”
Obviously, book-banning has become a concern among many Americans — but is it a serious problem, or is it primarily a political piñata?
Let’s start with some basic facts, which are rarely presented as part of the book-banning discussion.
One, in particular, stands out: According to data compiled by Bowker, which assigns book ISBN numbers, and reported by the authoritative trade journal Publishers Weekly, more than 4 million books were published in the United States in 2025, including 401,716 juvenile nonfiction and 265,615 juvenile fiction titles.
These are just a single year’s totals.
To put U.S. “book-banning” activities, or what the ALA has labeled “an organized effort to systematically suppress voices and ideas,” in perspective: Nationally, the ALA’s Office for Intellectual Freedom found “4,235 unique titles [were] challenged in 2025.” Raskin’s legislation claims 7,000 unique titles were “affected” between July 2025 and June 2026. Either way, skirmishes over books are clearly episodic, not epidemic.
More importantly, freedom of expression, a foundational American value, is not limited to freedom of speech and freedom of the press. It also includes the right “to petition the Government for a redress of grievances,” as the First Amendment explicitly states.
Which raises the question: Why do the ALA and its coalition partners seek to discredit and demonize those who raise objections to certain books found in taxpayer-funded libraries — and especially public-school libraries? Is the freedom of expression of such petitioners invalid?
Let’s be clear: No school district has the financial wherewithal, or the shelf space, to purchase every new juvenile title published. The same holds true for the broader library community.
Those who make the purchasing decisions must choose responsibly, exercising the best possible artistic, financial, and moral judgment.
Books that librarians choose not to purchase, and those that may be removed because of public objections or simply to make room for new titles, have not been banned; they are still available commercially, online or at a bookstore.
Although it is well established (yet still fiercely debated) that governments should have very little role in selecting public viewpoints, they have very much to say about what is taught in public schools, and are empowered by voters to appoint officials who choose curricula and select school library books and textbooks. Some of these choices will be questioned, often for good reason. Those who truly believe in freedom of expression should welcome that.
Most teachers have extensive freedom to provide a balance of perspectives to their students. Their selections set the tone for the kind of world their students will inherit and shape. As Mark Bauerlein, professor emeritus of English at my alma mater, Emory University, puts it: “When teachers craft their syllabi, they should ask, ‘What am I implying about the universe? What am I saying about the past? Am I handing them a world that they shall be eager to join?’”
His point: We are what we read. The job of teachers and librarians is to provide parents, students, and the public with reading material that enlightens us about the wider world.
That is not to say that it won’t also upset and enrage at times. And that’s okay. That’s why we have the First Amendment.
Richard N. Lorenc, former executive vice president of the Foundation for Economic Education, is president and CEO of Lexandria, an education nonprofit that seeks to reignite the American spirit through innovative classroom content and tools.
The views expressed by Guest Contributors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Issues & Insights editorial board.









Add comment