Issues & Insights
Chuck Schumer discusses the bad effects of the 2013 government shutdown. Source: Senate Democrats. Licensed under CC BY 2.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/deed.en).

As Shutdown Ends, Will Democrats’ Civil War Begin?

For the first time in decades, the Democrats have lost their bid to engineer a federal government shutdown, blame the Republicans for it, and win political concessions for doing so. Now that they’ve lost, they’re blaming moderates in their own party for the miscalculation. Let the blaming begin.

As is often the case, CNN’s unflappable, lonely conservative, Scott Jennings, predicted the outcome of the shutdown last week after Democrats posted big wins in blue states in the off-year elections. “I’m sure the Democrats will be happy to open the government now, the election is over,” he said, even as the Dems insisted that they wouldn’t.

But mere days after Jennings’ words, Democratic Sens. Dick Durbin, Tim Kaine, Maggie Kassan, Jacky Rosen, and Jeanne Shaheen, who had all voted 15 times against ending the shutdown, suddenly relented and crossed the aisle to vote to end the closure, joining original Democrat rebel Sens. Catherine Cortez Masto, John Fetterman, and Angus King.

And even the Dems’ media supporters admit the shutdown was entirely a Democrat political ploy, having little to do with sympathy for Obamacare recipients: “Democrats said the shutdown was about the subsidies, but for most of them, it wasn’t,” wrote Ezra Klein in The New York Times. “It was about Trump’s authoritarianism. It was about showing their base — and themselves — that they could fight back. It was about treating an abnormal political moment abnormally.”

He’s right, in a sense. It was cynical manipulation of the public for political gain — a perfect description of today’s far-left Democratic Party, in which moderation, common sense, and decency are treated not as virtues but as political treason. This is now the party of self-avowed socialist and Islamist Zohan Mamdani, new mayor of New York City. It is also the party of soon-to-be retired former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, whose main legacy, as one recent headline put it, “is the socialist takeover of her party.”

The loss isn’t sitting well with the Dems’ extreme-left wing, which did its level best to blame others in the party for what conservatives quickly dubbed “Schumer’s shutdown.”

“Pathetic. This isn’t a deal. It’s a surrender. Don’t bend the knee!” whined California Gov. Gavin Newsom in a press release.

“Tonight, eight Democrats voted with the Republicans to allow them to go forward on this continuing resolution. And to my mind, this was a very, very bad vote,” added “independent” Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders.

Dozens of other progressive Dems added their vitriol, throwing a collective fit on BlueSky.

The rage was palpable. Why? One big reason was that President Donald Trump promised to do what the Democrats had threatened to do in years past to end a shutdown: Kill the filibuster. (Not all Republicans agree with Trump, by the way.)

Democrats in recent decades have won shutdown fights by using their friends in the mainstream media to portray Republicans as evil, stingy villains who care not a whit about working people. They did it this time, too.

And this time it’s clear: Democrats were 100% at fault for this shutdown, and all its inconveniences. 

Moderate Democrats such as the eight who broke ranks to end the shutdown and Democratic Senate Leader Chuck Schumer will now find themselves pretty lonely amid the 37 other Democrats in the Senate. Some might be challenged from the left in their next primary. And all will also certainly find themselves short of friends and, in some cases, political funds. As a headline on Raw Story put it, “Angry Democrats brew ‘furious civil war’ after ‘lousy’ shutdown deal.”

As a party, the Democrats are in no mood to compromise or tolerate those who will. They believe once Trump is gone, they’ll again win elections that count, and GOP squishes in Congress will do their bidding.

In the meantime, their rage will turn on the small remnants of moderation and reason within their own party, leaving a giant hole for the socialists, antisemites, and wannabe revolutionaries who now run the Democrats to fill. Politics abhor a vacuum. The Democratic Party’s civil war will likely be the final triumph of its now-dominant socialist wing.

–Written by the I&I Editorial Board

Share

I & I Editorial Board

The Issues and Insights Editorial Board has decades of experience in journalism, commentary and public policy.

7 comments

  • Americans figured out Democrats are only about power and money – and controlling both – and not improving lives of working people. They also perceive Trump as the only one on their side, which may be true. George Orwell wrote: ‘All tyrannies rule through fraud and force, but once fraud has been exposed, they must rely exclusively on force.’ That is where the gravely wounded Democrat party finds itself. Look for them to become more violent.

  • lets hope so, if they destroy each other america will win and strike a blow to communism

    • Sure hope that the fight is real and not just another staged set up to confuse the people about the fact that both sides are working together for a much bigger agenda.

  • What we the people have with both
    POO-litcal bandits is a
    FAILURE to
    COMMUNICATE
    At the root of this is evil
    Is FREE MONEY FOR NOTHING
    No effort, no talent no Work
    Just being very Loud
    Shouting for more free things
    WHY
    Because like a baby
    It is now the way of life
    From cradle to grave
    For the donkey party’s
    Voters
    TAXS stolen at the end of a GUN
    By the IRS Since 1913
    I voted for a very stable genius to STOP THE MADNESS
    Trumps reply shut up here is
    Your 2000 dollar
    PAY OFF

  • We can only hope.
    Let’s do this, while I am still young enough to be of service to the US Republic.

  • Of course not. And we will just gat a repeat in January which is only 2 months from now. Schumer orchestrated the gang of 8 to break the shutdown, which allows the rest to scream about social injustices from the roof tops. Face it the AOC jeffries warrens of the d party are acting al high and mighty. With the LSM blessings.

About Issues & Insights

Issues & Insights is run by seasoned journalists who were behind the Pulitzer Prize-winning IBD Editorials page (before it was summarily shut down). Our goal then and now is to bring our decades of combined journalism experience to help readers understand the top issues of the day. I&I is a completely independent operation, beholden to none, but committed to providing cogent, rational, data-driven, fact-based commentary that the nation so desperately needs. 

Share

Discover more from Issues & Insights

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading