Issues & Insights

Is America In A Civil Disobedience Mood?

I&I Editorial

Governors, mayors, and county officials are again shutting down the activities and movements of an ostensibly free people, but this time the resistance looks like it will be more stubborn. No one is yet “up in arms.” But much of America has clearly had enough of the petty tyrants making rules for others.

Democratic Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti said Wednesday, with the iciness of a Versailles royal, that “it’s time to cancel everything.” Outdoor dining is now verboten in Los Angeles County, even though the restriction is “senseless.” (At least a clear-thinking judge has told the county that it must present scientific evidence that outdoor dining increases the risk of spreading the coronavirus if it’s to ban it.)

From her privileged and luxury bubble in Lansing, Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, another Democrat, is threatening to issue new stay-at-home instructions. California Gov. Gavin Newsom, the target of a recall effort, has delivered a similar warning. New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, whose pandemic response has arguably been the worst in the country if not the world, said he might again put out another statewide “pause” order. New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy, the third Democratic governor referenced in this paragraph, is saying that the malign presence (our words) of a shutdown “has to stay on the table.”

The Democratic governors of Oregon and New Mexico have also dropped heavy-handed restrictions on their states. And on it goes in the land that our grade school teachers told us was free.

But this time, unlike during the first lockdowns, which were to last for 15 days so we could flatten the curve of positive tests, many are not taking the undeserved punishment from their “betters” without a fight. Everyday Americans weary of being bullied from on high have been inspired by one-time Stanford University Medical Center neuroradiology chief and former White House coronavirus adviser Dr. Scott Atlas, who suggested Michiganders “rise up” – nonviolently – against Whitmer’s petty tyranny:

  • The owner of Eat At Joe’s in Redondo Beach, California, has been defying the Los Angeles County outdoor dining ban. “I’m not a person that easily wants to fight the system or anything,” Alex Jordan said. “I just, I hit my wall.”

Jordan served his last outdoor meal Thursday, reverting to takeout and delivery only. Threats to pull a company’s business license and/or shut off its power tend to have that sort of effect. At least Jordan got in a jab at hypocrite Newsom by hanging a French Laundry sign under his own.

  • A Staten Island bar has declared it is an “autonomous zone,” just as rioters did when they violently seized sections of Seattle and Portland earlier this year. The owner, who’s ignored shutdown orders as well as multiple fines, and wants others to also buck politicians’ authoritarian guidelines, has been arrested, as has the bar manager. A Republican state senator “was nearly arrested” as he tried “to force his way into” the establishment “less than 24 hours after officials issued a partial vacate order due to the establishment’s alleged flouting of pandemic restrictions.”

The New York Times deviated from its Democratic Party talking points long enough to perform some journalism when on Wednesday it reported the tavern is “a flash point in the Covid culture wars that have turned some business owners and party hosts into rebels against pandemic restrictions.”

The bar, Mac’s Public House, was closed by authorities Tuesday night. A video shot from overhead shows a large crowd gathering in protest.

“It’s time for all small businesses and citizens to stand up,” said owner Keith McAlarney. “If enough business owners throughout this city, state, country, open their doors and disobey these tyrannical orders, hopefully they can get their businesses back and we can get the country back to where it needs to be.”

  • In Loveland, Colorado, some restaurants and bars are continuing to serve patrons indoors. “More than 60 businesses announced Nov. 24 that they would not restrict their operations after Larimer County was moved into the red risk category,” the local media are reporting. “They said they would continue to follow the Level Yellow protocols.”
  • Business owners in Orchard Park, New York, who were meeting at a gym so they “could protest the closing of small businesses,” demanded a health department official and accompanying deputies remove themselves from the private property. The relatively mild confrontation ended peacefully. This time.
  • Both Whitmer and Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine, a Republican, have had articles of impeachment filed against them over their abuse of power during the pandemic.

The day before Newsom outlined a new stay-at-home diktat, the Los Angeles Times wondered “whether residents will stomach even a modified lockdown as willingly as they did in March and April.” Early indications say no.

“California Republicans urge the public to exercise civil disobedience and go against the tightened COVID-19 lockdown restrictions,” reports Christianity Daily

“James Gallagher, a Republican state assemblyman from Yuba City, urged the public to exercise civil disobedience and ignore the recently imposed rules,” while California Senate Minority Leader Shannon Grove and GOP Sen. Melissa Melendez have also expressed support for disregarding political directives.

Roughly half the country wants Joe Biden to ride into Washington and tell everyone in the country to go to their basement and stay there. But the other half knows lockdowns are worthless and probably even harmful, and is growing ever more enraged at elected and unelected officials using the police powers of the state to control their personal lives. Their patience and good will are thin and getting thinner.

How long before something ugly and regrettable happens because some politician who wouldn’t prosecute mobs, rioters and domestic terrorists ordered law enforcement to arrest citizens who were doing nothing but going about their daily lives?

Every COVID-19 death is tragic for that victim and his or her family and friends. But the death of liberty is catastrophic for all but the few who make the rules that restrict our freedom. Entire populations, not just a small portion, are lost when liberty dies. The effects linger for generations.

— Written by the I&I Editorial Board

We Could Use Your Help

Issues & Insights was founded by seasoned journalists of the IBD Editorials page. Our mission is to provide timely, fact-based reporting and deeply informed analysis on the news of the day -- without fear or favor.

We’re doing this on a voluntary basis because we believe in a free press, and because we aren't afraid to tell the truth, even if it means being targeted by the left. Revenue from ads on the site help, but your support will truly make a difference in keeping our mission going. If you like what you see, feel free to visit our Donations Page by clicking here. And be sure to tell your friends!

You can also subscribe to I&I: It's free!

Just enter your email address below to get started.


I & I Editorial Board

The Issues and Insights Editorial Board has decades of experience in journalism, commentary and public policy.


  • Yes it will be ugly but it will not be regrettable. Politicians will reap the harvest of the disenfranchisement of the people that elected them. The Tree of Freedom must oft be refreshed with the blood of both tyrant and patriot alike.

    • The Democrats won’t stop the restrictions, which will mean a kinetic fight to regain our freedoms. I dislike the thought very much but there’s no other way after what they did in stealing the election so brazenly.

  • America is far past civil disobedience. Will start with tar and feathers, to gallows in the public square to dangle the traitors at all levels of government. All tyrants and their sycophants are targets and will be hunted to exile or extinction.

    • Why would you be frightened? Read some history, (hint, 240 years ago) Do you want to go down like a wimp? Or do you want to be an American?

      • Have you ever actually been in combat. I have. 20 year retired vet. Yes, it frightens me because most of our citizens have no clue about the realities. You sound like a keyboard commando to me. I could be wrong and if you did then you have my thanks. In the meantime, don’t be so damned casual about it.

    • “Have you ever actually been in combat. I have. 20 year retired vet. Yes, it frightens me because most of our citizens have no clue about the realities.”


      I know plenty of guys who’ve seen real combat, and have serious scars to prove it, who don’t stoop to denigrating patriots with the “keyboard warrior” schtick.

      Apparently you are too emotionally scarred by your 20 year career to understand these people are expressing outrage at destruction and death in the streets of our cities and the rapidly collapsing rule of law at the hands of a whole bunch of people that express themselves *exactly* as you do.

      Further, I thought you “fought them over there so we don’t have to fight them over here.”

      Well, nice job, tough guy. They’re here now.

      I would thank you for your service, or whatever, but since your mouth is full of food bought with money taxed from my blood, sweat and tears, I think I’ll pass.

  • The simple answer to the question you pose is “yes.”

    While admittedly anecdotal, I’m seeing a growing frustration that will eventually lead to civil disobedience and, if allowed to continue, possible violent revolution.

    • The number of firearms buys in the last year are an indication that the plebes are getting ready.

  • The response to the lockdowns doesn’t have to be “ugly.” The disobedience can be in a very civil sort of way. What’s missing is leadership.

  • As long as 5% of alleged true committed responsible Americans rebel, while the other 45% who should be involved sit on their apathetic indifferent uncaring flatulent rears expecting more handouts and bailouts, nothing will genuinely change for the better, and you folks know it.

    Cue Padme from Revenge of the Sith, “so this is how liberty dies, to thunderous applause!…”

  • Not that it makes it any better but, at a bare minimum, any politician who chooses shutdowns (or any business restrictions) not only has to forego their own paycheck but they also have to do so for the government workers who work for them. Maybe then they’ll empathize with the small business owners who have to layoff their employees.

    • I said just yesterday that not a single federal, state or local government employee has missed a paycheck during all this. Not. One. Nor has any politician. That Americans are sitting still for this is astonishing to me.

  • The vote fraud and government by edict are all the same thing. Socialists distain government by the consent of the governed, because socialsts believe the people are too stupid and ignorant to give informed consent. Socialists think people are too stupid to take care of themselves on Wuhan virus, where the median age at death in the US is 79 and 92% of deaths with Covid-19 occur in patients 55 and over. Socialists also think people are too stupid to vote for the correct candidate for president, so they help them out. I hope the next 4 years are filled with lawsuits forcing socialists to actually follow the Constitution, state constitutions, state election law as passed and health laws without the “emergency” powers. For example, Witmer is ignoring the legal limits on her emergency powers right now. There should be a Go Fund Me to sue these folks and ask for jail time for contempt of court.

  • “Roughly half the country wants Joe Biden to ride into Washington and tell everyone in the country to go to their basement and stay there.”
    BuSSllhit….misspelling intentional.

  • I was outraged at the initial “15 days to slow the spread” and I haven’t changed my opinion. Thankfully I live in Florida where the governor has reined in the excesses of the county and city politicians and administrators. The virus has proven that it will continue to spread no matter the restrictions enacted. Why we’re allowing the state/county/city health departments to trample our Constitutional rights is beyond my ken.

    The Democrats RUINED the best economy since Reagan just to get rid of President Trump, and when it became obvious that it wasn’t going to work they doubled down and conspired to steal the election. I hate them with every fiber of my being.

About Issues & Insights

Issues & Insights is run by the seasoned journalists behind the legendary IBD Editorials page. Our goal is to bring our decades of combined journalism experience to help readers understand the top issues of the day. We’re doing this on a voluntary basis, because we believe the nation needs the kind of cogent, rational, data-driven, fact-based commentary that we can provide. 

We Could Use Your Help

Help us fight for honesty in journalism and against the tyranny of the left. Issues & Insights is published by the editors of what once was Investor's Business Daily's award-winning opinion pages. If you like what you see, leave a donation by clicking on donate button above. You can also set up regular donations if you like. Ad revenue helps, but your support will truly make a difference. (Please note that we are not set up as a charitable organization, so donations aren't tax deductible.) Thank you!
%d bloggers like this: