Issues & Insights
Tax The Rich, by Romain KOENIG, via Flickr. License: CC BY-SA 2.0.

Think Dems’ ‘Tax The Rich’ Policies Will Make America Better Off? Just Take A Look At California

Politicians love nothing more than spending, as our dangerously surging fiscal deficits clearly show. But rather than cut unnecessary spending, which would be the most logical thing, Democrats continue to push the dumbest non-solution for our soaring spending, deficits, and debt: tax the rich.

When asked why he robbed banks, Depression-era bank-robber Willie Sutton reportedly responded: “Because that’s where the money is.”

Funny, but elected Democrats in blue states today deploy the same logic in their growing calls to “tax the rich.”

As CNBC’s Robert Frank recently noted, “A new ‘blue wave’ of tax hikes on the wealthy is rippling through state legislatures, as Virginia, Washington state, Rhode Island and others join California in calls for higher taxes on top earners and billionaires.”

Don’t forget New York. There, a “Tax The Rich” rally on Wednesday in the state’s capital brought heavy backing from unions and far-left Dems, which in the Empire State means the entire Democratic Party.

Their proposal would, the New York Post editorial board notes, end up “socking not just millionaires but even couples making just $500,000, who’d see their taxes rise a whopping 10%. And top earners would face a top rate of 24% — the highest not just in America but the world.

And, of course, California is now discovering, to its shocked regret, that super-smart and ultra-mobile rich people and entrepreneurs don’t sit still to let their income and wealth be stripped off them by greedy leftist politicians.

No, they leave, taking their wealth, taxes, companies, and, most importantly, high-paying jobs with them.

California’s bitter experience should serve as an object lesson in capital flight. But socialists don’t care. They think your money should be theirs to spend. They use billionaires as targets, because there’s so much envy and resentment over their wealth.

Any state now contemplating punitive taxes on the wealthy would do well to learn from what’s happening to California, where activists, unions, and Democratic politicians are trying to get an initiative on the ballot called the “2026 Billionaire Tax Act.”

Its goal: to impose “a one-time 5% tax on billionaire wealth.”

It’s already having a nightmare impact on California’s economy, with at least seven entrepreneurial, job-creating billionaires relocating to friendlier states and taking their businesses, technology, and highly skilled and highly paid workforces with them.

And California’s already poorer for it.

As we noted last month, the billionaire tax is not “even officially on the California ballot yet, but that hasn’t stopped businessmen, entrepreneurs, and investors from fleeing the state, taking $1 trillion in wealth – along with jobs and opportunity – with them.”

It isn’t just billionaires. Other high-income taxpayers fear they will be next in line to have even more of their wealth and incomes taken by the state’s far-left legislature. They, too, are leaving in droves.

As Wayne Winegarden of the Pacific Research Institute observes, the disincentives to entrepreneurial investments are a disaster in the making for California.

PRI’s own economic and tax model shows that “the size of California’s economy could shrink between 3% and  6.7% relative to the baseline. Further, the growth in the average household’s income would be between $1,900 and $4,300 smaller, the growth in jobs would be between 200,000 and half a million less, and the exodus of people from the state would increase between 43,000 and 95,000.”

In short, the state’s war on success will leave it poorer, smaller, and politically weaker.

What’s truly tragic is that Democrats hope to take this campaign national. And if they regain control of Congress in 2026, you better believe they’ll try.

Americans beware. Avoid the siren song of “tax the rich,” the notion that by seizing all or part of billionaires’ assets and income, America would get rid of its trillion-dollar deficits and suddenly be flush with cash. It’s a lie.

As the National Taxpayers Union Foundation explains:

On average, … the federal government spent about $19.2 billion per day (in 2025). At this level of spending, raising the average federal tax rate on the top 1% from its current level of 26.09% to 30% would fund the government for only 6 additional days. Even … seizing the entire income of the top 1% by taxing them at an average federal rate of 100% would not even fund the government for half a year — only raising enough revenue to fund 127 days of government spending.

“Tax the rich” is a bankrupt slogan of far-left Democrats as they try to siphon even more money from society’s most creative class — its entrepreneurs, inventors, and builders — and waste it instead on the worst-run part of our economy: Big government.

— Written by the I&I Editorial Board

Share

I & I Editorial Board

The Issues and Insights Editorial Board has decades of experience in journalism, commentary and public policy.

2 comments

  • California use to be one of the most beautiful havens in the country.
    Citizens migrated to Cal. because of the weather, the palm trees, the ocean, the people.
    But today-due to the political predations of Dem. political leaders-if California citizens can avoid stepping over the homeless (who may be residents on their lawns); can tip-toe over used syringes (that are everywhere on the streets), can be lucky enough to have their children come home (after a day of avoiding mentally addled drug users or illegal immigrants who now drive commercial trucks), they can now go swipe their brows and go to bed peacefully-dreaming that their cars on the streets or home where they live are safe and sound.
    Hah! It’s not a dream;it’s a nightmare because crime in now a growing industry where California Courts protect-not the law abiding-but the criminal.
    Yes, California use to have everything. Today, they have everything else, from wildfires to higher taxes on accumulated wealth to Political Correctness run rampant.
    Pretty soon all the wealthy will migrate to other states that not only treat them better but don’t seem to have a vendetta against the successful. Thus, there will not be enough taxpayer funds to pay for California’s foolishness.
    California will not sink into the sea-but they will wish they had. At least it would-even with the saltwater-get it cleaner.

  • It is becoming more and more obvious that the left and the democrats are destroying our great cities with intent and are successful in their destruction. Is there a master mind or total incompetence? Either one is evil. Our great cities are disappearing. The intent seems a great intent and right before our eyes.

About Issues & Insights

Issues & Insights is run by seasoned journalists who were behind the Pulitzer Prize-winning IBD Editorials page (before it was summarily shut down). Our goal then and now is to bring our decades of combined journalism experience to help readers understand the top issues of the day. I&I is a completely independent operation, beholden to none, but committed to providing cogent, rational, data-driven, fact-based commentary that the nation so desperately needs. 

Share

Discover more from Issues & Insights

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading