In response to last week’s editorial “None Dare Call It A Republic,” one reader said I&I prefers “the term republic over democracy because” we “like the Republican Party” and “don’t like the Democratic Party.” Therefore we refuse to use the word “Democratic” because it “sounds just like the word ‘democratic.’” We can’t say we like the Republican Party, but we can say we despise the Democratic Party. Read on and we’ll tell you why.
First, though, take a look at the reader’s full comment, found here. He calls us ignorant, which is fine – he’s entitled to his opinion. But his statement reminds us quite a bit of the gibberish yakked up by Joe Biden in last year’s presidential debate, which was so incoherent that in one instance Donald Trump said “I really don’t know what he said at the end of that sentence. I don’t think he knows what he said either.”
But we understand enough of what our dedicated reader said to feel that it would be helpful to explain why we don’t like the Democratic Party, and not just so readers will understand but also to make it clear just how dissolute that party is.
We could start with its lust for big government and all that comes with it: steep taxes, cruel regulation, appalling violations of property rights and an imperious and ever-hungry administrative state.
Or we could frame our argument in terms of civil society vs. political society, with the Democrats hard in favor of the latter, which is a serial violator of liberty.
Instead we’ll focus on what the Democrats want over all: a revolution.
Don’t mistake this “revolution” for any similarities with our own war for independence from the British crown. That war was fought to slough off the heavy hand of government and found a nation built on liberty and independence.
The Democrats want a revolution that would turn that achievement on its head.
We know this because the late David Horowitz has provided “the receipts,” as the kids would say. In his book “Barack Obama’s Rules for Revolution: The Alinsky Model,” he recounts what a Students for a Democratic Society radical wrote during the turbulent 1960s:
The issue is never the issue. The issue is always the revolution.
“In other words the cause,” says Horowitz, originally a far-left activist who later committed his life to the cause of freedom, “whether inner city blacks or women – is never the real cause, but only an occasion to advance the real cause which is the accumulation of power to make the revolution.”
This is why the “big tent” Democratic Party attracts disparate groups, such as environmental activists, eager central planners, redistributionists, anti-gun scolds, antifa goons, COVID tyrants, neo-New Dealers, radical Islamists, militant transgender moms, pride cultists, race hustlers, criminal coddlers, infanticide advocates, male-hating feminists, DEI zealots, busybodies, nannies, groomers, dancing geriatrics and raging protesters who have no idea what they’re protesting.
(Why does this list remind us of the “Blazing Saddles” scene in which the scheming Hedley Lamarr, played brilliantly by Harvey Korman, ordered Slim Pickens’ Taggart to round up a gang of “rustlers, cut throats, murderers, bounty hunters, desperados, mugs, pugs, thugs, nitwits, halfwits, dimwits, vipers, snipers, con men …”?)
That the groups listed above have little to nothing in common yet fit snugly together is no mystery. Their grievances are not their grievances, they are merely means for a revolution, or, as we sometimes seem to be heading toward, a civil war.
The Democratic Party’s intersectional politics are why Greta Thunberg can shift from climate warrior to a Hamasnik wearing an Arafat keffiyeh (also known as the “hipster swastika”) and no one on the left blinks. They furnished the stage for Barack Obama to promise that if elected, he’d get busy “fundamentally transforming the United States of America,” and be cheered as if he were a deliverer having descended from Olympus.
The revolution that the Democratic Party has been pressing for at least six decades would abolish capitalism and free markets, seize the means of production, destroy the nuclear family, erase Christianity and Judaism, defund law enforcement, reopen the borders, censor speech, pack the Supreme Court, ration energy and health care, overturn our civil order and uproot Western civilization.
Our “democracy loving” Democrats want a regime they fully control, a subservient proletariat, unchallengeable compliance, all life “within the state, nothing outside the state, nothing against the state.”
We hope we’re wrong, that one day rather than saying “we told you so,” we’re admitting our mistake. It would be best for our nation if that’s how it turns out. What makes us doubt that will happen is the Democratic Party, as constructed, does not want what’s in the best interests of the country, but instead wants what’s in the best interest of its political power.
— Written by the I&I Editorial Board




Thank you. This is one of the best pieces you’ve written. Absolutely nailed it, especially the explanati
I agree 110%. Well written with the essentials clearly stated. Democrats in their current form must be stopped for the good of freedom in this country. Democrats offer the opposite of freedom by promoting big government solutions to everything and censoring anything that doesn’t fit their script.
Great article!! So true!
Ursbfurrer, writing nearby beat me to this, but this was an excellent editorial — a succinct summary of problems among the so-called “Democrats”. At least it summarizes most of what I fear from them. The only thing left out is their truly scary “ad hoc” approach to the rule of law.
Great article, but I have one major quibble. The opposition is the DEMOCRAT Party, not the democratic party. There is NOTHING democratic about democrats!!! You are allowing them to co-opt another word for their own description instead of the commonly known description.
100% correct.
Every source I’ve looked at calls them the Democratic Party. I looked at 9 or 10 different sites and they’re all the same.
A 2021 survey found that 42% of Americans didn’t know that Lay’s potato chips are made from potatoes. Wonder how those 42% vote . . .
Obama’s “Fundamental transformation” speech still curdles my blood to this day. That the legacy media gave virtually no response to that speech tells me everything I need to know of their intentions.
I was going to say that the Democrats believe in nothing except opposing anything President Trump is for. Your article shows me that was too simplistic. They want a 1917 type revolution. They want to be the red army. They never talk about democracy(where Trump won the popular vote), it’s always OUR DEMOCRACY. “Our Democracy” in their parlance, seems to be creating an autocracy where they rule.
The Democrat party is drowning in a death spiral and keeps surfacing and gasping for relevance. The Democrat party will either end up being reinvented or replaced.
The amazing characteristics about Democrats are their lack of understanding of what motivates us all, their willing forgetfulness of their policies that have failed, and their acceleration off the cliff with even more far fetched policies they claim will help “their little people,” but which backfire badly for billions of our tax money on the people everyone wants to help.
The dependable characteristic about Democrats is that they are consistently wrong. Why does such a political party still exist?
It’d be simpler to just say that democrats believe they’re slave masters. I mean, it’s not like every democrat alive doesn’t believe he / she / it / whatever doesn’t absolutely know to their core that they know how everyone should live their life better than each individual does.
When the Democrats use the term “Our Democracy”, you have to hear it capitalized like that, and understand what it really means. It is yet another one of their famous euphemistic shibboleths like “fetus” or “reproductive rights”. When they say “Democracy” they don’t mean “democracy” as in rule by the people. For them fascism means things they don’t like and Democracy means things they do like. And when they say “Our” they don’t mean “our” as in belonging to all of us. They mean theirs as in the Democratic Party’s.
“Our Democracy” has nothing to do with voting or elections. It just means Rule by the Democratic Party. It is the opposite of democracy, and we rightly seek to destroy Their Democracy, and restore democratic republic that the Founding Fathers created.
Brilliant…you could’ve included school choice and the great lengths the Teachers union monopolists have fought vouchers, charter schools (read Sowell’s book on this topic).
Indoctrinating the youth to hate their country is shameful
“the Democratic Party, as constructed, does not want what’s in the best interests of the country, but instead wants what’s in the best interest of its political power.” and THIS is what the dems/left/authoritarians are all about.
“… I&I prefers “the term “republic” over “democracy”, because” we “like the Republican Party” and “don’t like the Democratic Party.” Therefore we refuse to use the word “Democratic” because it “sounds just like the word ‘democratic.’”” – Article
“The ideal of a democracy is universal equality. The ideal of a constitutional republic is individual liberty.
“A democracy always degenerates into dictatorship, which promises government-guaranteed equality and security. But it delivers nothing but poverty and serfdom for the people it robs and rules.
“America was founded as a constitutional republic , so as to safeguard the liberties of the people, against the tyranny of democracy or of one-man dictatorship.
“In this century, great strides have been made toward the goal of subverting our republic into a democracy. The foremost tactic of the subverters is subversion of language. By calling America a democracy, until people thoughtlessly accept and use the term, the totalitarians have obscured the real meaning of our principles of government.” – Dan Smoot, from “The Dan Smoot Report” program on television, 1966
Glenn made a funny comment, which was, in a poll, 42% of Americans didn’t know that Lay’s Potato Chips were made from potatoes. Then he asks, “I wonder how they voted?”
I don’t know how they voted, but I bet Joe Biden was one of the ones polled.
Good read, thanks. I started out like many on the boomer generation: starry’eyed progressive “green.” After half a lifetime in democrat controlled California government, I came to realize from the inside that everything you are saying here is true. In my second life as a conservative, I was still a government regulator, but I’ve learned to see things with eyes wide open.
Yes, it has always been about them, not you or me.
Also, “Methodists!”
According to historian Patrick K. O’Donnell in his book “ The Unvanquished..” The Democrats of the antebellum South used the term “The Democracy.” They’ve never changed.
Yes. And after the revolution the Bolsheviks will eat the rest.
It is what it is.
I prefer the word “Republic” because that’s what we are. People who use “Democracy” are either demagogues or didn’t pay attention in their Civics class.
Brilliant expose on what the dems want. A herd of sheep they can move about like a checker board. Lets hate this group for a while then move on like locust. Its their brand and they loved it until Trump shut the spigot off.
Because the island of misfit toys is so 1950’s, and we need to be inclusive so, the party of misgendered boys it is..