Issues & Insights
President Trump waves to the media. Source: Rawpixel. Licensed under CC0 1.0 (public domain).

GDP’s Small Drop Brings Out The Media’s Anti-Trump Jeers

Let’s get the big news out of the way: The economy shrank by 0.3% during the first quarter of 2025, a mild but not wholly unexpected drop blamed by nearly everyone on President Donald Trump’s tariff hikes. Is that the first step toward a recession, or, as Trump put it, just a result of the “Biden overhang”?

First, let’s just note one big thing: The media can’t help but show its glaring bias against Trump even when it reports boring data, such as the barely negative GDP number.

Honey, Trump shrunk the economy! And the lying coward is still blaming Biden,” as a particularly crass opinion on USA Today said.

Everything is fine: Trump’s cabinet shrugs off shrinking economy,” smirked the AFP news service’s sarcastic headline. The story asked: “Contraction? What contraction?”

In case you didn’t get that quote, it was a play on the clueless remark (“Crisis? What Crisis”) supposedly uttered by British Prime Minister James Callaghan, after being asked about his collapsing economy during the disastrous “Winter of Discontent” in 1979.

Then there was Newsweek’s effort: “Trump Loses First Round of Trade War as U.S. Economy Shrinks, China’s Grows.” As any competent economist will tell you, China’s economic data are not reliable. So comparing U.S. data to China’s numbers, is misleading at best.

So let’s repeat. This is a 0.3% drop in GDP, not a collapse. And Trump is no bungling leftist British leader like Callaghan, whose tenure in office was so disastrous it led to Conservative Margaret Thatcher’s record run of nearly 11 years as prime minister.

But more to the point, let’s look at why GDP fell, which is interesting.

Did tariffs play a role? They did, even though they weren’t in effect during the first quarter.

But businesses always prepare for changing circumstances. As it turns out, U.S. and foreign companies anticipated Trump’s promised tariffs on foreign-made goods by front-loading imports during the first quarter.

And boy, did they front-load them. Imports soared at a 41.3% annual rate during the first quarter as businesses brought in all the foreign goods they could, tariff-free. As a matter of calculation, imports subtract from GDP.

So that 41.3% surge in imports reduced GDP by 5%. In short, mere anticipation of the tariffs caused the decline, not the actual tariffs themselves. Add back even half of that 5% hit to GDP, and a very different picture emerges.

And when you look at a more substantive measure of underlying economic demand, such as final sales to domestic purchasers, you see a 3% annual rate of growth, a step up from the fourth quarter’s 2.9% pace.

In short, the bottom isn’t falling out of the economy, though it still remains burdened by the Fed’s string of 11 interest rate hikes from March 2022 through September 2024, when it finally began trimming rates. Fed interest rates remain high today, but the residual effects of Bidenomics and its destructive inflation still haven’t worn off.

To be sure, Trump’s tariffs spooked the stock market, as investors tried to figure out how the new system will affect corporate earnings and the real economy. The bellwether S&P 500 Index of major companies is off about 8% since Trump took the oath on January 20.

But while investment markets are vital, there’s another little-noticed investment boom going on: Companies such as Johnson & Johnson, Apple, Nvidia, OpenAI, Oracle, SoftBank, Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company, and even the United Arab Emirates, have together pledged more than $2 trillion in new U.S. investment over the next decade.

Just this week, pharmaceutical giant Merck announced a $1 billion plant to make its anti-cancer drug Keytruda. Other foreign drugmakers such as AstraZeneca, Novartis and Roche are also building plants in the U.S. to avoid tariffs.

That’s long-term potential for trillions in added U.S. output and millions of new jobs for Americans.

As our good friend Steve Moore at the Committee to Unleash Prosperity reminds us, “investment (the impetus of long-run real economic growth) soared, up 22% . . . This is the rocket fuel for future growth that America needs. This was the opposite of tepid business investment under Biden.”

So, yes, tariffs have made for a rocky start. For the record, we’re tariff skeptics ourselves. Even so, once tariffs are sorted out and Congress fulfills its pledge to cut taxes, growth will almost certainly return and America’s heartland will again hum with the sound of modern factories. America is resilient.

Until then, Trump will get no breaks from the anti-Trumpmedia. There’s already a steady drumbeat of negativity, with daily predictions of looming recession, just as in his first term. Any mistakes, any weaknesses, always excused under President Joe Biden, will immediately be flung in Trump’s face.

— Written by the I&I Editorial Board

Share

I & I Editorial Board

The Issues and Insights Editorial Board has decades of experience in journalism, commentary and public policy.

3 comments

  • I liked your analysis of the effect front-loaded imports had on first quarter GDP. First of all, this is just the first revision. I have seen revisions that go from negative to positive and vice versa several times. I always question first quarter numbers because of several factors. A good Christmas season (celebrating a Trump victory) would provide a higher 2024 4th quarter and a lower 2025 1st quarter. Paying off the credit cards – not as much money to spend. Weather – people do not go shopping if it is freezing or the streets are filled with snow. The cold leads to more money in the pockets of the utilities but not the American consumer. Quick question: How many times in the Obama administration were there negative 1st quarter GDP numbers? The leftist media did not tout an oncoming recession, then. They only bash President Trump. Next question: What value are GDP numbers, now, when two straight negative quarters of GDP ( my olde definition of a recession) occurred during the Biden administration and it was not called a recession, again, by the biased leftist media. Then again, there was the 800,000 jobs discrepancy. I do not trust any of the numbers from the past four years and I think it is foolish to put much credence to them.

  • I haven’t read this anywhere, but Government spending and the DOGE firings (due to redundancy, inefficiency or corruption) and closing of Government offices affect the GDP.
    All will affect downward the GDP: For example the Firings will mean fewer employees which means fewer GDP goods will be bought. The same with closing Government Offices. Less office equipment or upkeep is demanded.
    So as Government spending falls so will the GDP. The same with the closing of Government offices and the firing of Government employees. The Government is slimming down.
    Just because an obese person loses weight does not mean he is beginning to kill himself. Actually, he’s getting healthier.
    Larry Kudlow reports Business Investment increased, I believe, 10%-and Business Investment in Machines and Equipment (which is the precursor of new jobs, new wages and new prosperity) increased an incredible 20%.
    Now, I don’t believe I’m a Pollyanna, but not mentioning these points is not mentioning a significant reason of the decline (I believe it’s about a 1.2% decline in a yearly projection) and ignores a big part of the reality of the situation.
    In my opinion Trump is doing what is necessary. For many decades our past Presidents have ignored a very real problem: We, in effect, have been supporting foreign countries in their predation of our own markets.
    This has led to the disappearance of our manufacturing base-a base which we will need for national security reasons.
    For instance, not having enough steel to build our planes is dangerous and could put us at peril, if the nations we depend on to sell us our steel have become enemies.
    Moreover, any war with one of the nations who are not our adversaries could affect our sea lanes and supply chain (if our enemy controls these) so that we can no longer get steel that we bought.
    Trump’s tariff prestidigitation is successfully restoring our manufacturing base; putting a very real adversary (Red China) as a disadvantage; and giving our economy a domestic B-12 shot.
    While GDP is down, it (in my opinion) is understandable down-just the GDP data doesn’t reflect reality. For instance, GDP is based on prices not items. Inflation (according to the CPI) has fallen. So, how much of the decline in GDP is due to to falling inflation? I don’t know-but falling inflation and GDP macro-data are connected.
    We all owe President Trump a debt of gratitude, not only on [for] his work of addressing this problem, but being the first President (Republican and Democratic) to identify it.

  • It would be nice to know what the amount of new US investment was during Biden’s term.

kill the ads

For every $20,000 raised, we will eliminate One Ad Spot until we are completely ad-free!

To support this cause, click HERE.

Created using the Donation Thermometer plugin https://wordpress.org/plugins/donation-thermometer/.$100,000Raised $13,178 towards the $100,000 target.$13,178Raised $13,178 towards the $100,000 target.13%

So far, we have raised $13,178 toward our $100,000 target!

Once we reach $100,000, we will be free of Big Tech overlords!

Help us Kill the Ads! click HERE.

About Issues & Insights

Issues & Insights is run by seasoned journalists who were behind the Pulitzer Prize-winning IBD Editorials page (before it was summarily shut down). Our goal then and now is to bring our decades of combined journalism experience to help readers understand the top issues of the day. I&I is a completely independent operation, beholden to none, but committed to providing cogent, rational, data-driven, fact-based commentary that the nation so desperately needs. 

Share

Discover more from Issues & Insights

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading